Researchers identify security vulnerabilities in voting app

Now, MIT researchers are raising another concern: They say they have uncovered security vulnerabilities in a mobile voting application that was used during the 2018 midterm elections in West Virginia. Their security analysis of the application, called Voatz, pinpoints a number of weaknesses, including the opportunity for hackers to alter, stop, or expose how an individual user has voted. Additionally, the researchers found that Voatz's use of a third-party vendor for voter identification and verification poses potential privacy issues for users.

The findings are described in a new technical paper by Michael Specter, a graduate student in MIT's Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (EECS) and a member of MIT's Internet Policy Research Initiative, and James Koppel, also a graduate student in EECS. The research was conducted under the guidance of Daniel Weitzner, a principal research scientist at MIT's Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Lab (CSAIL) and founding director of the Internet Policy Research Initiative.

After uncovering these security vulnerabilities, the researchers disclosed their findings to the Department of Homeland Security's Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Agency (CISA). The researchers, along with the Boston University/MIT Technology Law Clinic, worked in close coordination with election security officials within CISA to ensure that impacted elections officials and the vendor were aware of the findings before the research was made public. This included preparing written summaries of the findings with proof-of-concept code, and direct discussions with affected elections officials on calls arranged by CISA.

In addition to its use in the 2018 West Virginia elections, the app was deployed in elections in Denver, Oregon, and Utah, as well as at the 2016 Massachusetts Democratic Convention and the 2016 Utah Republican Convention. Voatz was not used during the 2020 Iowa caucuses.

The findings underscore the need for transparency in the design of voting systems, according to the researchers.

"We all have an interest in increasing access to the ballot, but in order to maintain trust in our elections system, we must assure that voting systems meet the high technical and operation security standards before they are put in the field," says Weitzner. "We cannot experiment on our democracy."

"The consensus of security experts is that running a secure election over the internet is not possible today," adds Koppel. "The reasoning is that weaknesses anywhere in a large chain can give an adversary undue influence over an election, and today's software is shaky enough that the existence of unknown exploitable flaws is too great a risk to take."

Breaking down the results

The researchers were initially inspired to perform a security analysis of Voatz based on Specter's research with Ronald Rivest, Institute Professor at MIT; Neha Narula, director of the MIT Digital Currency Initiative; and Sunoo Park SM '15, Ph.D. '18 , exploring the feasibility of using blockchain systems in elections. According to the researchers, Voatz claims to use a permissioned blockchain to ensure security, but has not released any source code or public documentation for how their system operates.

Specter, who co-teaches an MIT Independent Activities Period course founded by Koppel that is focused on reverse engineering software, broached the idea of reverse engineering Voatz's application, in an effort to better understand how its system worked. To ensure that they did not interfere with any ongoing elections or expose user records, Specter and Koppel reverse-engineered the application and then created a model of Voatz's server.

They found that an adversary with remote access to the device can alter or discover a user's vote, and that the server, if hacked, could easily change those votes. "It does not appear that the app's protocol attempts to verify [genuine votes] with the back-end blockchain," Specter explains.

"Perhaps most alarmingly, we found that a passive network adversary, like your internet service provider, or someone nearby you if you're on unencrypted Wi-Fi, could detect which way you voted in some configurations of the election. Worse, more aggressive attackers could potentially detect which way you're going to vote and then stop the connection based on that alone."

In addition to detecting vulnerabilities with Voatz's voting process, Specter and Koppel found that the app poses privacy issues for users. As the app uses an external vendor for voter ID verification, a third party could potentially access a voter's photo, driver's license data, or other forms of identification, if that vendor's platform isn't also secure.

"Though Voatz's privacy policy does talk about sending some information to third parties, as far as we can tell the fact that any third party is getting the voter's driver's license and selfie isn't explicitly mentioned," Specter notes.

Calls for increased openness

Specter and Koppel say that their findings point to the need for openness when it comes to election administration, in order to ensure the integrity of the election process. Currently, they note, the election process in states that use paper ballots is designed to be transparent, and citizens and political party representatives are given opportunities to observe the voting process.

In contrast, Koppel notes, "Voatz's app and infrastructure were completely closed-source; we were only able to get access to the app itself.

"I think this type of analysis is extremely important. Right now, there's a drive to make voting more accessible, by using internet and mobile-based voting systems. The problem here is that sometimes those systems aren't made by people who have expertise in keeping voting systems secure, and they're deployed before they can get proper review," says Matthew Green, an associate professor at the Johns Hopkins Information Security Institute. In the case of Voatz, he adds, "It looks like there were many good intentions here, but the result lacks key features that would protect a voter and protect the integrity of elections."

Going forward, the researchers caution that software developers should prove their systems are as secure as paper ballots.

Website search

Recently updated

Bitdefender Internet Security 2018 Bitdefender Internet Security 2018 Antivirus solution with firewall, antispam, anti-ransomware, password manager, parental control, vulnerability scanner, autopilot, intrusion detection, and more
Bitdefender Total Security 2018 Bitdefender Total Security 2018 Anti-malware solution with anti-theft, anti-phishing, firewall, autopilot, rescue mode, intrusion detection, ransomware protection, parental control, browser sandbox, password manager, and more
eScanAV AntiVirus Toolkit eScanAV AntiVirus Toolkit Analyzes important areas of your computer, such as the registry, system folders, startup items, running services and the memory to detect potential dangerous content

Software News

Feb 14
At a time when cyberbullying and unhealthy messaging are running rampant online, social networking sites are grappling with how to address it.
Feb 14
It's being called nasty-oh, the reinfection of it all- and sneaky for good reason: It's all of that, known to headache-watchers as xHelper, which turns out to be of no help at all once infected. The malware xHelper was ...
Feb 13
A storyline with emotionally evocative details can reduce virtual reality cybersickness for some people, according to a new study.
Feb 13
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in using internet and mobile technology to increase access to the voting process. At the same time, computer security experts caution that paper ballots are the only secure ...
Feb 7
If you resort to deleting apps when your phone's storage space is full, researchers have a solution.
Feb 6
A flaw that gave out root privileges gets patched. It is a utility that, said Dan Goodin in Ars Technica, can be found in "dozens of Unix-like operating systems."
Feb 5
The creative force behind the Grand Theft Auto video games, Dan Houser, will leave next month the Rockstar Games firm he cofounded, its parent company said.

About us

Welcome to new crack resource CrackDownloadz.com! Our service can generate cracks, keygens and serials for your software to unlock it. CrackDownloadz provides a lot of popular cracks and keygens. No spyware and adware at all, just download new cracks, keygens and serials. If you have a software that needs a crack feel free to contact us.

Also you may contact us if you have software that needs to be removed from our website.